- TRT Trasporti e Territorio
Transcript
- TRT Trasporti e Territorio
G H G - Tr a n s P o R D : reducing greenhouse gas emissions of transport beyond 2020: Linking R&D, transport policies and reduction targets Findings on European R&D and GHG reduction potentials Dr. Wolfgang D W lf Schade S h d Fraunhofer-ISI Coordinator of GHG-TransPoRD Angelo A l M Martino ti Trasporti e Territorio Srl, TRT Seite 1 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Agenda The GHG-TransPoRD project R&D and innovations in the transport sector GHG reduction p potentials in road sector GHG reduction potentials in rail sector GHG reduction potentials in maritime sector Seite 2 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 O b j e c t i v e o f G H G - Tr a n s P o R D Suggestion of an integrated strategy for the EU that links R&D policy for transport with a transport policy strategy such that the European GHG reduction targets for 2020 and 2050 can be met also for transport. Expected results: Reduction targets for transport R&D strategy Transport policy strategy Project framework Funded by European 7th Research Framework Programme (~950 k€) Project j duration 24 months ((Oct. 1st 2009 to Sept. p 30th 2011)) Five project partners from five European countries Seite 3 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 P r o j e c t s t e p s o f G H G - Tr a n s P o R D Analysis of R&D efforts in transport Analysis of innovation system and diffusion of innovations in transport sector Measures for GHG reductions ((long g list)) Potentials of GHG reductions of measures (short list) Cost analysis of GHG reduction measures Scenarios and integrated assessment of R&D strategies and policy strategies Seite 4 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 R&D and innovations in the transport sector Seite 5 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Structure of sectoral system of innovation (Kuhlmann & Arnold, 2001) Demand Framework conditions Consumers (final demand) Producers (intermediate demand) Financial environment; taxation and incentives; propensity to innovation and entrepreneurship; mobility ... IIndustrial d ti l System Education Ed i and d Research System Political P liti l System Large companies Government Intermediaries Professional education and training Research institutes Brokers Higher education and research R&I policies Public sector research Governance Mature SMEs New, technologybased firms Infrastructure Banking, venture capital Seite 6 IPR and information Innovation and business support Standards and norms Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Potential reach of public policies Low carbon automobile industry innovation system Market Regulation Demand Framework conditions Values Old / young Energy industtries: power ge eneration, oil p producers Intern national trad de of vehicle es Transport Infrastructure Industrial System Vehicle producers Auto majors Service operators Financial environment; taxation and i incentives; ti propensity it tto innovation i ti and entrepreneurship; mobility ... Lobby Network Education and Research System Political System Professional education and training EU Government Higher education and research National Government Public sector research R&I policies Logistics / Services R&D Departments OEMs Knowledge Networks (e.g. Joint ventures) Niche companies (not small companies) G Governance Innovation Infrastructure Standards and a d norms o s Subsidies R&D support Source: GHG-TransPoRD D1 Schade/Martino Seite 7 IPR and information Banking, e u e cap capital a venture Political impacts Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Climate and environment policy In nternational policies (q quotas, CDM M, GATT) Consumers ((final demand)) Producers (intermediate demand) R&D of European transport sector in the global context R&D investment (€bn) World EU27 Automotive manufacturers Sales (€bn) World Number of employees (million) World EU27 EU27 53 20.9 1,213 423 2.76 1.26 19.6 9.5 437 156 2.33 0.98 6.9 2.4 233 66 0.62 0.22 Aerospace and defence 15 6 15.6 75 7.5 379 129 1 74 1.74 0 55 0.55 'Transport' sector 95.1 40.3 2,262 774 7.5 3 All industries i d ti 431 130 13 897 13,897 5 712 5,712 45 1 45.1 21 Automotive suppliers li Commercial vehicles and trucks Source: GHG-TransPoRD D1, based on EU Scoreboard 2009 (DG RTD-IPTS, 2009) (rounded numbers) Seite 8 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Distribution of European automotive R&D efforts – focus on GHG reductions Total R&D R&D for GHG reductions Electric vehicles (€1.4-1.7bn) Conventional engines (€5-6bn) R&D - Other R&D activities (safety, comfort, etc.) Biofuels (ca. €0.4bn) R&D - GHG emissions i i reduction ~€32bn €10-11bn Fuel cells (€0.5-0.6bn) s Other GHG Oth emission reduction technologies R&D - Air pollutant emissions reduction ~€13.5bn Source: GHG-TransPoRD D1 Seite 9 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 European patents in hybrid and electric vehicles by country and period DE 2004‐2007 FR IT 2000‐2003 GB SE 1996‐1999 AT NL 1992‐1995 FI 0% 20% 40% 60% 80% Source: GHG-TransPoRD D1 Seite 10 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 100% RoEU27 Strategies to develop electric vehicles (EVs) (Status April 2010) Automotive supplier Automotive manufacturer Battery manufacturer Electricity supplier JV = Joint Venture Valeo JV ‘HL Green Power Co.’ Hyundai LG Chem Hitachi Michelin Dong Energy General Motors JV Honda Tesla Motors JV ‘Blue ‘Bl Energy’ E ’ Renault ‘Better Place Denmark’ F.S.I. Toyota A123 Systems CEA JV ‘Panasonic Electric Vehicle Energy’ JV Nissan EDF SAIC Motor Panasonic GS Yuasa JV ‘Lithium Energy Japan’ PSA Mit bi hi Mitsubishi NEC TOKIN Corp. Suzuki JV AESC Sanyo JV Magna Int. Vattenfall (Volvo, Sweden) VARTA Microbattery FORD Toshiba BYD JV JV ‘Li-Tec’ JV Continental Enax Johnson Controls (e.g. Berlin) Daimler ‘e-mobility Italy’ Enel E.ON Source: GHG-TransPoRD D1 Seite 11 Volkswagen Saft JV (e.g. Munich) BMW Evonik ‘e-mobility Berlin’ RWE JV ‘LIB 2015’ BASF Bosch Samsung SDI JV ‘SB LiMotive’ Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Cobasys Estimating GHG reduction potentials: energy framework Seite 12 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Reference energy demand trend up to 2050 (by mode in PJ/year) GHG‐TransPoRD Energy Framework 30000 [PJ] 25000 Air 20000 Ship 15000 Rail 10000 Road 5000 0 2010 2020 2030 2040 Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 Seite 13 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 2050 Reference energy demand trend up to 2050 (by fuel type in PJ/year) GHG‐TransPoRD Energy Framework 30,000 [PJ] Biofuel (road) 25,000 Hydrogen Electricity (rail) Electricity (rail) 20,000 Kerosene (air) 15,000 CNG (car) LPG (car) ( ) 10,000 Diesel (ship) Diesel (road & rail) 5,000 Gasoline (road) ‐ 2010 2020 2030 2040 2050 Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 Seite 14 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 GHG reduction potentials in road sector Seite 15 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Example fact sheet explaining GHG reduction measures “Aerodynamics and resistance” summary The group of measures assigned to “aerodynamics and resistance” contains measures that aim at reducing the aerodynamic resistance, the mechanical resistance of tires and the friction within engines in passenger g cars. Aerodynamics and resistance consists of a combination of five measures: Measures included improved aerodynamics (e.g. via smooth under flow or lower car bodies), reduced engine friction losses, low resistance tires (reducing energy wasted as heat), tire pressure monitoring system (controlling if the tire pressure is efficient) efficient), tire-pressure low viscosity lubricants (decreasing the mechanical friction in engines) Energy intensity Field of influence Earliest implementation date Partially already implemented % for o a all passe passenger ge ca cars s 2020 EU27 7% Relative CO2 2050 EU27 9% for all passenger cars reduction Measure is applicable on all new passenger cars. Applicability EU15 50.4 Mt CO2 Absolute 2020 CO2 EU12 10.1 Mt CO2 reduction EU27 60.5 Mt CO2 potential 2050 EU15 66.2 Mt CO2 EU12 16.4 Mt CO2 Description EU27 Feasibility 82.6 Mt CO2 High Maturity In process Cost 1,059 €/Ton CO2 saved Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 Seite 16 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 GHG reduction potentials cars (long list) Nr. Measures / Technologies 1 Reduced mechanical friction components 2 Low viscosity lubricants 3 Low rolling resistance tires 4 Improved aerodynamics 5 Tire-pressure monitoring system 6 Substitution of fossil fuel by battery electric vehicles 7 Control mechanism for servo-steering 8 Electric power steering (EPS) 9 LED headlights 10 Pneumatic brake booster I lli ffuell pumps 11 Intelligent Solar panels on roofs 12 13 High efficiency alternators 14 Intelligent battery sensor 15 CNG 16 LPG 17 Electrohydraulic valve gear 18 Variable compression ratio 19 Cylinder deactivation 20 Variable valve actuation 21 Start-stop system 22 Variable valve timing 23 Fuel quality sensor CO2 Reduction Min Max 0.4% 5.0% 0.5% 4.0% 2.0% 2.0% 1.5% 1.8% 1.0% 1.0% 7 8% 7.8% 7 8% 7.8% 3.1% 5.0% 2.0% 3.0% 2.5% 1.6% 2.5% 0 3% 0.3% 0.3% 17.0% 29.0% 0.5% 2.0% 1.5% 1.5% 16.7% 16.7% 9.0% 10.0% 5.0% 10.0% 2.1% 8.0% 3 0% 3.0% 7 0% 7.0% 3.0% 4.0% 1.0% 3.0% 1.2% 1.2% Nr. Measures / Technologies 24 Latent-heat storage 25 Intercooling 26 Dual cooling circuits 27 Exhaust heat recuperation 28 Cooling fluid shutdown system 29 Hybridtype: full 30 Hybridtype: mild 31 Brake energy recuperation 32 Hybridtype: plug-in 33 Homogeneous Charge Compression Ignition i h stratified ifi d charge h ((stoichiometric) i hi i ) 34 GDI with GDI with stratified charge (lean burn) 35 36 GDI with homogenous charge (stoichiometric) 37 Piezo injectors 38 Further penetration of gasoline direct injection 39 Utilisation of lightweight design and materials 40 Weight reduction by minimising convenience features 41 Smaller capacity fuel tanks 42 Continuouse variable transmission 6 speed manual/automatic gearbox 43 6-speed 44 Dual clutch transmission 45 Piloted gearbox 46 Optimisation of gear boxes Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 Seite 17 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 CO2 Reduction Min Max 8.1% 8.1% 2.5% 2.5% 0.5% 2.0% 1.5% 1.5% 1.0% 1.0% 18 0% 18.0% 22 0% 22.0% 10.0% 11.0% 3.0% 3.0% 11.0% 8 0% 8.0% 4.3% 0.7% 3.0% 0.9% 4.9% 2.0% 2.1% 2 5% 2.5% 4.0% 4.0% 1.0% 25.0% 14.0% 6.4% 5.0% 3.0% 20.0% 4.9% 3.0% 9.0% 5 0% 5.0% 5.0% 4.0% 2.0% GHG reduction potentials cars (short list): 2020 Injection Technology Electrical System ‐ Energy Supply Heat/Cooling Management Lightweight Construction Engine Control System Hybrid Vehicles Hybrid Vehicles Aerodynamics/Resistance CNG/LPG Battery Electric Vehicles El Electrical System ‐ i lS E Energy Demand D d Drive and Transmission Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicles 2020 0 0 10 10 20 20 30 30 40 40 50 50 60 60 [Mt CO2] Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2, Remark: usage of biofuels was subject to separate analyses Seite 18 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 70 70 80 80 90 100 90 100 GHG reduction potentials cars (short list): 2050 // Battery Electric Vehicles Injection Technology Electrical System ‐ Energy Supply Hybrid Vehicles Lightweight Construction Heat/Cooling Management Heat/Cooling Management Engine Control System Aerodynamics/Resistance CNG/LPG H d Hydrogen Fuel Cell Vehicles F l C ll V hi l Electrical System ‐ Energy Demand Drive and Transmission // 700 0 0 25 50 25 50 75 75 100 100 125 150 175 200 225 250 275 300 125 150 175 200 225 250 275 300 2050 [Mt CO2] Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 Seite 19 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 GHG reduction potentials in rail sector Seite 20 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Overview of rail transport selected measures Hybrid shunting 1 Reeduction pootential (%)) 40 Supercapacitors 14 35 30 Regenerative braking 25 20 75 Aerodynamic efficiency 15 Energy efficiency 41 10 Innovative bogie 5 11 Low Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 21 Seite 21 11 Friction control Medium 100 Light weight material High Feasibilityy Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Scope (%) Ranking of rail transport selected measures 4 500 4,192 Energy efficient driving Regenerative g braking g Aerodynamic efficiency Supercapacitive energy storage Hybrid shunting locomotives Light weight materials Friction control measure Innovative bogie [Kton] CO O2 reductioon 3 000 2 995 2,995 2 000 1,560 1,406 1,333 929 1 000 586 85 0 2050 Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 22 Seite 22 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 CO2 reduction provided by rail transport measures The implementation p of the selected measures to the rail sector allows reducingg CO2 emissions of 10% by 2020 and 42% by 2050 within EU27, assuming that all measures could be contemporarily implemented. On total transport emissions, rail measures impact is 0.1% byy 2020 and 0.6% byy 2050 [ton] 31 408 455 25 460 236 -2 442 303 -13 13 085 959 Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 23 Seite 23 2020 2050 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 CO2 rail emissions CO2 saving GHG reduction potentials in maritime sector Seite 24 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Overview of maritime transport selected measures Measure name Policy measure Earliest introduction date Feasibility ‐ Imo Indices In process High Already implemented Already implemented High High Already implemented Already implemented In process In process In process Medium Medium Low Low Already implemented Already implemented High High Already implemented High Technical measures A) Overall vessel design A) Overall vessel design ‐ Lightweight materials ‐ Ship resistance B) Engine andpropulsion systems ‐ Contra‐rotating propeller ‐ Dual‐fuel engine ‐ Flettner rotor ‐ Sky sails system Sky sails system C) On‐board energy using systems ‐ Automation ‐ Waste heat recovery system D) Port and infrastructure ‐ Shoreside power at ports Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 Seite 25 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Ranking of maritime transport selected measures Sh Shoreside power at ports id Waste heat recovery system Automation Flettner rotor Sky sail systems Dual fuel engine CRP Ship resistance Ship resistance Lightweight materials 0.0% 1.0% 2.0% 3.0% 4.0% 5.0% 2050 2020 The impact of the selected measures ranges from <1% to 5% in relation with the maritime energy framework in 2020 and 2050. Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 Seite 26 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 CO2 reduction provided by maritime transport measures CO2 maritime emission CO2 ii i i CO2 savings 1 926 144 367 ‐7 427 2020 2 555 180 484 Kton ‐25 25 001 001 2050 CO2 savings from maritime measures about: 5% in 2020 and 14% in 2050. Source: GHG-TransPoRD D2 Seite 27 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Summary Road / Cars C Technically, CO2 emission reduction of -40% up to -45% until 2020 feasible In the long term (2050) even -60% up to -68% realistic (excluding EVs) Injection technology, electrical system (energy supply) and heat/cooling management bear highest reduction potentials until 2020 (~10% each) Batteryy electric vehicles could contribute CO2 reductions of -77% until 2050 ((with power supply mix of reference scenario) Road / trucks bears smaller but also significant reduction potentials Rail sector can pprovide GHG reductions of -10% until 2020,, and -42% until 2050 Maritime sector has potentials of -5% until 2020, and -14% until 2050 Absolute reduction potential of transport sector in order of -30% 30% in 2020 2020, up to -60% 60% in 2050 Potentials would even be higher if electric power generation is shifted to zero GHG emissions by 2050 Seite 28 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010 Contact Dr. Wolfgang Schade, Area Coordinator Angelo Martino, Director Fraunhofer Institute Systems and Innovation Research (ISI) Trasporti e Territorio Srl , TRT Breslauerstr. 48, 76139 Karlsruhe, Germany Phone: +39 (02) 57 41 03 80 Phone: +49 721 6809 353 Fax: +39 (02) 55 21 28 45 Fax: +49 49 721 6809 135 E il [email protected] Email: ti @t tt ti t it i it Via Rutilia, 10/8, 20141 Milano, Italy Email: [email protected] Seite 29 Schade/Martino Primo Forum tedesco-italiano per la mobilità – Bergamo, 25th November 2010